Is it a situationship or a relationship?
If you can't say what you two are, what you each want, or where it's headed, it's a situationship. When most of it lives in the thread, the fix is one clear conversation, not another week of decoding.

Jump to a section
How do I know if we’re actually in a relationship?
If you can’t clearly say what the two of you are, what each of you wants, or where it’s headed, you’re in a situationship. The way out is almost always one direct conversation, not better decoding of their texts.
A relationship isn’t defined by how often you see each other or how close it feels at 1 a.m. It’s defined by both people knowing, out loud, that it’s a thing.
What actually counts as a situationship?
A situationship has some of the parts of a relationship (time together, sex, inside jokes, a hoodie that lives at your place now) without a shared, spoken agreement about what it is.
Take Rhea, 24, four months into something with Gabe, 25. They hang out two or three nights a week. She knows his coworkers’ names from his stories. She spent a whole Sunday helping him carry a couch up three flights to his new place. But she’s never met his friends, she has no idea whether he’s still on the apps, and last Friday she watched him go “Active now” at 1:12 a.m. and couldn’t decide if she was allowed to mind. When her roommate asked “so are you two dating?”, Rhea laughed and said “it’s complicated.” That’s the tell.
Communication researchers Leanne Knobloch and Denise Solomon call this kind of not-knowing relational uncertainty, and they split it into three pieces:1
- Self uncertainty: Do I actually want this to be more?
- Partner uncertainty: Do they want this to be more?
- Relationship uncertainty: What is this, and where is it going?
A situationship usually runs all three at once. No wonder it’s hard to think straight.
Why don’t you just ask?
Because uncertainty makes the question feel dangerous. In a 2004 study of 216 people, Leanne Knobloch and K. E. Carpenter-Theune found that people who felt more relational uncertainty also avoided more topics with their partner.2 When you can’t predict how someone will react, saying nothing feels safer.
That’s the loop. Uncertainty makes you avoid the talk, and avoiding the talk keeps you uncertain. Rhea has typed “what are we” in her Notes app more than once. It’s still there.
Why does it take up so much headspace?
Because not knowing is sticky. In a 2011 study in Psychological Science, Erin Whitchurch, Timothy Wilson and Daniel Gilbert showed college women the profiles of several men. Some were told the men liked them a lot, some that the men liked them an average amount, and some that it could be either.3 The unsure group was the most attracted, more than the group told they were liked a lot. They also thought about the men the most, and that extra thinking was linked to the stronger attraction.3
That was a lab study with strangers, not people four months in. But the mechanism maps neatly onto your phone. Rereading Thursday’s text. Checking who viewed your story. Wondering if “we should go to that thing” means next month or never. The not-knowing makes you think about them, and thinking about them can feel a lot like feelings.
Is this just how dating works now?
Partly. According to Pew Research Center’s 2022 survey of U.S. adults, 53% of adults under 30 have ever used a dating site or app, and one in five partnered adults under 30 met their current spouse or partner on one.4 The apps make it easy to meet people and easy for things to stay loose, since there’s always a sense that someone else is a swipe away.
But loose isn’t the same as what people want. In a 2012 review of hookup research, Justin Garcia and colleagues cited their own 2010 survey of 681 college-aged adults, in which 63% of the men and 83% of the women said they’d prefer a traditional romantic relationship to an uncommitted sexual one.5 Plenty of people in casual setups are quietly hoping for more. Sometimes both people in the same one.
How can you tell if it’s going anywhere?
No checklist can predict another person. But a few things are worth noticing:
- Does it spread, or stay in one lane? Relationships tend to spill into the rest of life: friends, birthdays, plans more than a week out. Situationships often stay in the same small box for months.
- Do plans have a future tense? “Come to my roommate’s birthday next Saturday” is different from “you around tonight?”
- Can you ask the small stuff? If “are you still on the apps?” feels impossible to say, that avoidance is information.
- Are you deciding, or sliding? Researchers Scott Stanley, Galena Rhoades and Howard Markman describe couples who slide through big transitions without ever deciding, and argue that the inertia this builds may raise the risk of later distress for some couples.6 Their work was about moving in together, but the idea fits earlier too. Four months can become a year without anyone choosing it.
What to do tonight, and this week
- Tonight, answer your own question first. Finish this sentence privately: “What I want from this is…” If you can’t, start there. Self uncertainty is a real piece of the fog.
- Take the thread out of the group chat. Five friends voting on one text won’t tell you what they think. Only they can.
- Turn the thread into a plan. Day, place, time. Then ask in person, at a calm moment. Not at 2 a.m., not after they cancelled, not by text if you can help it.
- Say what you want before you ask what they want. “I like this and I’d like us to be dating for real” keeps you from bending your answer to fit theirs.
- Ask once, then listen. “I’m not sure yet” is a real answer. So is “no.” Either one gives you something the silence never did.
- If they dodge, name it once. “I noticed we skipped past that. I’d still like to know.” A second dodge is information too.
And if what you want is to keep it casual, that’s fine. The point isn’t forcing a label. It’s both of you knowing what you’ve agreed to.
Rhea asked Gabe on a Saturday, walking back from the laundromat. He said he’d been wondering the same thing and didn’t know how to bring it up. Not every version ends that neatly. But it took four minutes, and the rehearsing took four weeks.
What doesn’t the research show?
- The attraction study used strangers, a single lab session and only college women. It shows uncertainty can boost interest in the moment, not that it predicts how anything turns out.3
- Uncertainty research is mostly correlational. It links uncertainty with avoiding topics, but can’t prove one causes the other in your situation.2
- “Situationship” isn’t a research term. Studies talk about uncertainty, casual relationships and hookups, so applying them to your life is a reading, not a diagnosis.
- Some casual setups genuinely work for both people, especially when they’ve actually talked about it. The research is about ambiguity, not about casual dating being bad.
- The sliding-versus-deciding work focused on couples moving in together, not people a few months into dating.6
Try it
Tick what's true with this person right now
Steal this text
Say it in your own words, or start from these
If you want to keep it light
Okay, real question, zero pressure: I like this a lot and I'm curious what we're doing. Tacos Thursday and we talk about it like two normal people?
If you want to be direct
I've really liked these months with you, and I'd like us to be dating for real, just us. How are you feeling about it? Any honest answer is okay.
If they dodged it last time
I noticed we skipped past the us question last time. I'd still like to know where your head's at. Can we talk Saturday?
People who talk about this
- Credentialed source
Alexandra H. Solomon
Relational self awareness, dating and building lasting relationships, drawn from her couples work and her Northwestern course.
- Credentialed source
Justin J. Lehmiller
Research on sex, desire, casual relationships and friends with benefits.
- Credentialed source
- Trending voice
Nedra Glover Tawwab
Boundaries in relationships, family and friendship, and how to say what you need.
- Credentialed source
- Trending voice
Ramani Durvasula
Narcissistic and high conflict relationships, and recovering after leaving one.
Further reading
Cleveland Clinic
What Is Breadcrumbing? How To Handle It (opens health.clevelandclinic.org)Names the pattern of just-enough attention that keeps you hooked, and how to respond to it.
Sources
- Measuring the sources and content of relational uncertainty
- Topic Avoidance in Developing Romantic Relationships: Associations With Intimacy and Relational Uncertainty
- He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not . . . : Uncertainty Can Increase Romantic Attraction
- From Looking for Love to Swiping the Field: Online Dating in the U.S.
- Sexual Hookup Culture: A Review
- Sliding Versus Deciding: Inertia and the Premarital Cohabitation Effect